Welcome!

For my senior initiative in 2011, I went around all five boroughs of New York City to find the best pizza. After testing each venue, I updated the blog with my review of the slice and some photos of the pizzeria. I already visited a huge list of places, but if you have any recommendations, don't hesitate to e-mail me at dso35@cornell.edu

Thanks for visiting the blog and giving me your support. Please comment on the reviews, to do so, click on the title of a post and scroll to the bottom. Be sure to come back for more updates!

-Daniel Ortega
Showing posts with label Manhattan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Manhattan. Show all posts

Monday, May 23, 2011

John's Pizzeria

Hidden within the bright lights and excessive tourism that make up Times Square, John's Pizzeria seems like an ordinary New York City eatery from the outside. Once you enter, however, you will see how deceptive John's Pizzeria is, housing an enormous restaurant that is consistently packed with guests. I had been to John's before, and I was really looking forward to my first visit in over a year.



Pizza Overall Grade: A

Cheese: 5
Sauce: 4
Bread/Crust: 4.5
Presentation: 5
Pizzeria: 5
Service: 3

Wow. My experience at John's pizzeria definitely topped my previous visit to John's, and possible my visits to all of these other pizzerias. When entering John's, one might not expect to see a two-story restaurant inside with a huge wall mural, along with decorative art nearby each and every table. When the pizza arrived to the table, I was astounded by how great the pizza looked. Even though they are responsible for satisfying a large crowd, John's pizzeria was able to serve me and my friends two perfect pies. The funny thing is, the pizza tasted better than it looked! The cheese was my favorite type of cheese: one that is both stretchy and flavorful. The cheese really trumped the sauce, but the sauce was good too. The bread and crust were very thin and acted well as a support to the pizza itself.

The only thing I can complain about John's Pizzeria was the service. Our table was confused at one point because one waiter told us refills were free when another said they weren't. Also, the food took longer than a normal pie usually takes, but the venue was busy that night. Another thing is that the pies are smaller than usual, even if you order a large pie.

I gave John's Pizzeria an A because the pizza and the pizzeria were amazing. I would definitely come here again to enjoy both the beautiful scenery and the delicious pizza. It was so good, after our meal, we had to order another pie!



John's Pizzeria is located at 260 W44th Street, between 7th and 8th avenue in Manhattan.
Phone: (212) 391-7560
Delivery, Take-out, Eat-in
Cost of Pie:   Small (13.75)    Large ($15.75)
Dept. of Health Grade: A

Wednesday, May 11, 2011

Patsy's Takeout Pizza

Patsy's is arguably the most famous pizzeria in Harlem. There are two separate places where pizza is sold: one in a restaurant and one in a small space for take-out pizza. I trekked my way to the take-out Patsy's to try some of their famed pizza. Many say Patsy's is so great because it is cheap and affordable (slices are only $1.75).

*****NOTE: Pasty's Take-out is different from Patsy's Pizzeria Restaurant. I will be visiting the restaurant soon and giving a completely different review with its own grade *****


View Larger Map


Pizza Overall Grade:  C-

Cheese: 3
Sauce: 3
Bread/Crust: 1
Presentation: 1
Pizzeria: 2
Service: 3

I have to say, I was completely surprised by my visit to Patsy's Take-out. The first thing that struck me was the slice of pizza itself. Despite being cheap at a mere $1.75, the slice was smaller than a normal slice of pizza. Also, the pizza crust was burnt black on one corner, along with some patchy spots of missing cheese. The pizza itself was not too bad, however, I could not get over how burnt the crust was. The pizzeria itself was not spacious enough for even three people to eat inside, since there was a randomly placed vending machine inside the small venue. The service was pretty good, my food was fresh and made in a fair amount of time.

Another important thing I noticed was that the Department of Health Grade was missing. Either the pizzeria did not post it up on the front window, which is illegal, or they did not receive a grade yet. I checked online and saw that they had 11 violation points, which corresponds to an A (More than 28 points requires the venue to be shut down).

I gave Patsy's a C- because my experience was horrible. Not only did the pizza look bad, but it was not as good as I expected. I may have had the wrong pie or visited the wrong day, but what happened is now set in stone.

*****NOTE: Pasty's Take-out is different from Patsy's Pizzeria Restaurant. I will be visiting the restaurant soon and giving a completely different review with its own grade *****

The Patsy's Take-out pizzeria I visited is located on 2287 1st Avenue (Between 117th and 118th Streets).
Phone: 212-534-9783
No Delivery, Take-out
Cost of Slice: $1.75
Dept. of Health Grade: N/A (8 violation points, corresponding to an A)

Thursday, May 5, 2011

Famous Famiglia's Pizza

Famiglia has a franchised name with the local pizzeria feel. With a few locations around the city, Famiglia has become a familiar name for most New Yorkers. I found that the Famous Famiglia Pizzeria located on West 96th Street was recommended more than other pizzeria on the Upper West Side. Intrigued, I ventured my way to see whether or not their self-proclamation, "New York's Favorite Pizza" lived up to the hype.


***This rating was done upon request of a close friend, and despite this being a franchise, I reviewed this particular location***







Pizza Overall Grade: B

Cheese: 2
Sauce: 4
Bread/Crust: 5
Presentation: 2
Pizzeria: 2.5
Service: 5

The pizza itself at this Famiglia was pretty good. The sauce was much better than the cheese on the pizza, which is sometimes great when the sauce is well-made. The bread and crust of this slice of pizza was paper thin, yet it made an incredible impact on my lunch. At this Famiglia, the service was excellent. The food was both prepared quickly and served with a smile by a very friendly staff of employees. Many regular customers had clearly grown close to the pizzeria and its employees, something that is essential to a great pizzeria.

One of the things I didn't like about the pizza was that it looked messy when I received it. Famiglia receives a lot of orders everyday, so they cannot prepare their pizzas to perfection. Still, I never like seeing a slice of pizza with patches of missing sauce or cheese. Also, the pizzeria tables were quite dirty. With my order in my hands I looked for somewhere clean to sit, and I could not find a spot that had been wiped down.

I gave Famiglia a B because the pizza was pretty good, but it was not incredible. The pizza and the pizzeria seemed to messy as well. The pizzeria did receive an A for its health inspection though. Nevertheless, I was expecting more from Famiglia, but maybe its franchised name might make it more difficult to keep expectations high. If you are around the area, definitely have a slice, but I would not go out of my way to eat this pizza.

Famiglia is the official pizzeria of the following:
-The New York Yankees
-Six Flags
-Hershey Park
-Madison Square Garden
-Palms Hotel and Casino

Famiglia is located in 25 different states with over 20 venues in New York City. 

The Famous Famiglia Pizzeria I reviewed is located on 734 W 96th Street at Amsterdam Ave.
Phone: (212) 749-1111
Cost of Slice: $2.75
Dept. of Health Grade: A

Wednesday, May 4, 2011

The Original Mike's Pizza

******************************
UPDATE: Mike's Pizza is no longer in business
******************************

Mike's Pizza is one of the most popular places to eat for Dalton students during school hours. For some, the pizzeria's proximity to the school makes the whole difference. For others, the pizza is what truly matters. As a regular Mike's customer myself, I know both of these factor into my decision making every time I go out to eat. The pizza itself, however, will be the main consideration in this review.


Pizza Overall Grade: B+/A-

Cheese: 4.5
Sauce: 3
Bread/Crust: 5
Presentation: 4.5
Pizzeria: 2.5
Service: 5


One of the main reasons why I love Mike's pizza is because of the cheese and the crust. There is a perfect thin layer of cheese that is both not too cheesy and not too light. The crust is always sturdy but crisp enough to crack and keep the pizza intact. The sauce isn't the richest but the cheese masks its taste. Mike's is also great for always giving a great looking slice every time you order. Slices from Mike's don't ever fall apart or get messed up when being cut from a pie. One thing that keeps people coming back to Mike's is the great, friendly service. The food is always prepared quickly, as pizza should be. There is also a 'Dalton Special' at Mike's, where you can get a slice of pizza and a small fountain drink for just $3.

In Mike's Pizzeria, there isn't much space inside to eat. With only 4-6 chairs, there is rarely space to sit and eat with company. It is also hard to navigate when there are about 8-10 people trying to order and eat their pizza.

I gave Mike's a B+/A- because the pizza's taste and friendly service were outstanding. Mike's has a few issues with space, but aside from that it is a great place to have a slice of pizza.

The 'Original' Mike's Pizzeria is located on 1315 Lexington Avenue between 88th and 89th Street.
Phone: (212) 369-9000
Free Delivery
Cost of slice: $2.50
Dept. of Health Grade: A

Honorable Mentions:
-Chicken Roll